Cuddlefish › New York

Tompkins Square Bagels

165 Avenue A, New York, New York, 10009

Must-tryRecommended on camera by 1 food creator

Order the The Jeremy

“This is the only bagel in New York City that you are not allowed to toast.”

See it on the mapWebsite

Who recommended it

• Jeremy Jacobowitz@jeremyjacobowitz · January 2026Watch the reel →

More places food creators recommend in New York.