Cuddlefish › Indianapolis

St. Elmo Steakhouse

127 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, Indiana, 46204

Must-tryRecommended on camera by 1 food creator

Order the Shrimp cocktail

“The spice runs up your nose into your eyeballs and after a few seconds of pain it dissipates. It doesn't linger like a spicy pepper and most importantly it is absolutely delicious. And integral to the St. Elmo experience.”

See it on the mapWebsite

What they ordered on camera

• Shrimp cocktail
• Espresso martini
• Elmo Cola
• Chopped BLT
• Steaks
• Filet
• House made onion rings
• Skillet mushrooms

Who recommended it

• The Eric Hammer@theerichammer · April 2026Watch the reel →

More places food creators recommend in Indianapolis.