Cuddlefish › Brooklyn

Peter Pan Donuts

727 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, New York, 11222

Must-tryRecommended on camera by 1 food creator

Order the everything bagel breakfast sandwich with ketchup

“This classic donut shop in Brooklyn is hiding the best bagels in New York City.”

See it on the mapWebsite

What they ordered on camera

• everything bagel breakfast sandwich with ketchup
• sour cream cake donut

Who recommended it

• Jeremy Jacobowitz@jeremyjacobowitz · September 2026Watch the reel →

More places food creators recommend in Brooklyn.