Cuddlefish › Staten Island

Criollas

451 Northfield Ave, Staten Island, New York, 10303

Must-tryRecommended on camera by 1 food creator

Order the coconut, milk chocolate, and white chocolate alfajores

“Criollas might be tucked away underground, but it's definitely a hidden gem worth finding”

See it on the map

Who recommended it

• Priya | Seattle + Philly/NYC Food and Travel Content Creator@priyas_plates · July 2025Watch the reel →

More places food creators recommend in Staten Island.